The Hajj – One-Way Ticket to Heaven?

Is the Saudi government to blame for the stampede that has claimed 769 lives?

There was a time when Muslims from the subcontinent bought one-way tickets to sail to the port of Jeddah, the entry point on the Hejaz coast along the Red Sea for performing the Hajj.

A Muslim is exhorted to perform the Hajj, at least once in his/her lifetime, subject to physical and financial ability. It is regarded as one of the five pillars of Islam.

It was a perilous journey which started with relatives and friends bidding a tearful farewell to the potential Hajji, since many, particularly the elderly, never returned.

The Hajjis faced many obstacles on the journey from Jeddah to Mecca. The harsh Arabian weather, lack of water and Bedouin robbers often left defenceless pilgrims stranded to face the inevitability of death in the desert.

Those who managed to reach Mecca sometimes died during the pilgrimage, succumbing to harsh weather conditions or sickness.

The dead were mourned but also celebrated because to die while performing Hajj was to ensure instant entry into Jannat or Heaven. Not many returned home and acquired the aura that came with prefixing their names with the title ‘Al-Hajj’.

The chief Saudi mufti has declared all the dead as ‘martyrs’ as if that would be some consolation for the bereaved families.

Worst Tragedy in 25 Years

The tragedy last week snuffed out over 750 lives and injured over 800 pilgrims, during the annual Hajj ritual of stoning the Devil at Mina, a few kilometres from Mecca.

This incident again highlights a recurring theme that has dogged the Hajj for hundreds of years.

The pilgrims were caught in a massive stampede that was triggered when millions of them were going towards Mina and returning.

Sickening Regularity of Similar Incidents

In 2006 after another similar carnage, the Saudi authorities erected three massive pillars and constructed a bridge with five levels to facilitate the stoning of the Devil ritual, spending over $1.2 billion.

Yet there is a sickening regularity to these accidents. This time pilgrims across 15 nationalities have lost their lives, including 29 from India so far.

With over 2 million pilgrims turning up for the Hajj, it is a logistical nightmare for Saudi Arabia to manage. The Saudi authorities have been found wanting many times. There is a wrenching history of deaths during the Hajj.

In 1990, over 1,420 pilgrims died in the worst such incident in the history of the Hajj.

The carnage last week is the second deadliest incident and comes days after the deaths of over 100 pilgrims at the Grand Mosque in Mecca when a construction crane on the site fell crashing down inside the mosque.

Iran Blames Saudi Arabia; Saudi on Defensive

Iran which has said that 131 of its nationals have been killed has been particularly trenchant in its criticism.

Iran’s Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei directly blamed Saudi authorities for “mismanagement” and Iranian officials have weighed in by accusing Saudi authorities of “tactlessness” on safety procedures. Iran has charged the Saudi authorities as “irresponsible”, saying that they must be held accountable and has declared three days of mourning.

Instead of blaming this and that, the Saudis should accept the responsibility and apologise to the Muslims and the victims’ families.
— Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, Iranian Supreme Leader

While the Saudi Ambassador has been summoned to receive a protest at the Iranian foreign ministry, the Saudi authorities have been on the defensive.

This is not a situation with which to play politics. I would hope that the Iranian leaders would be more sensible and more thoughtful with regards to those who perished in this tragedy and wait until we see the results of the investigation.
— Adel al-Jubeir, Saudi Foreign Minister

Some officials have blamed pilgrims for not following guidelines and lacking patience and one official has acknowledged that for an unknown reason two walkways from Mina had been closed, forcing pilgrims into massing on other walkways and causing the stampede.

The Saudi Crown Prince has ordered an enquiry and called it a tragic incident. By all accounts the elderly, the infirm and physically weak pilgrims constitute the bulk of the dead and wounded.

Inadequate Infrastructure and Mismanagement

The principal cause of these recurring stampedes seems to be the rush of pilgrims competing with one another to complete the rituals within the stipulated time frame.

There are too many pilgrims all converging at the same site, pushing and shoving to throw seven stones at the Devil. Failure of management and inadequate infrastructure adds to the chaos.

By all eyewitness accounts gathered by the international media, the failure of the Saudi authorities at crowd control caused the tragedy.

While Saudi Arabia claims to have spent billions on infrastructure, it also earns billions from the annual pilgrimage by charging fees for all services and facilities.

Saudi Arabia is one of the richest countries in the world having amassed huge wealth as a major oil producing country. It is, therefore, not hard pressed for funds.

Religious Monopoly

Sometime in the 1980s, the Saudi king adopted the title of ‘Custodian of the two holiest Sites’ in an obvious attempt to take over the mantle of religious leadership of the Islamic world.

The repeated tragedies during Hajj have raised serious concerns about Saudi Arabia’s ability to handle the Hajj which draws more and more pilgrims from across the world.

It is clear that the Saudi authorities have ignored safety concerns that have been raised from time to time.

In a country that is so regimented and controlled, it is not surprising that some of the billions spent on managing the Hajj have been misdirected for personal profit.

One obvious reason is the over-emphasis on building malls and hotels that have restricted open spaces for the movement of such a large number of pilgrims.

The other reason is total lack of public accountability in an opaque and authoritarian system. No one has ever been punished for mismanagement that has caused so much human suffering.

This tragedy is a major challenge to the new Saudi King and his revamped administration, all drawn from the ruling family.

The Saudis have got involved in the war in Yemen and in India, recently, a Saudi diplomat was accused of rape and trafficking women.

Apart from the docile and obedient Saudi media and its counterparts in the Gulf sheikhdoms, there is no sympathy for the Saudis in the regional media. For the Saudis, the scorecard has been pretty poor of late.

Critics in the Arab world have echoed earlier calls for handing over the management of the Hajj to a special international Muslim body or the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC).

This is clearly anathema to the Saudis and there is no need to hold one’s breath for this to happen.

(The author is a Distinguished Fellow at the Observer Research Foundation and a former Secretary in the Ministry of External Affairs. He served as a young diplomat in Saudi Arabia)