.jpg?rect=1%2C0%2C1820%2C1024&auto=format%2Ccompress&fmt=webp&width=720)
The scratchy, echo-filled tape recording carries the voice of a man who once was in line to become Iran’s supreme leader, talking about one of the darkest moments of the country’s post-revolution history still not recognised by its government.
The recording has Grand Ayatollah Hossein Ali Montazeri condemning Iran’s execution of thousands of prisoners at the end of the country’s bloody war with Iraq in 1988. He warns those gathered they’ve committed “the biggest crime in the history of the Islamic Republic,” while criticising them for misleading the country’s then-ailing supreme leader, Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini.
The criticisms by Montazeri, who lived for years under house arrest and died of natural causes after Iran’s disputed 2009 presidential election, long ago surfaced in his own memoirs and writings. But the furore ignited by the release of the tapes by his family this month expose the lingering, unhealed wounds of the chaotic years that followed Iran’s 1979 Islamic Revolution, as well as politics now at play in the greater West Asia.
“All advice and criticism from my father was for saving the ruling system — which he had paid so much for,” his son, Ahmad Montazeri, recently wrote online.
In 1985, Montazeri was selected as Khomeini’s successor. But Montazeri’s calls for the loosening of clerical control in Iran drew the ire of hard-liners — and then came the executions.
They happened at the end of Iran’s long war with Iraq, which began when Saddam Hussein invaded in 1980. By 1988, 1 million people had been killed in a conflict that featured trench warfare, Iranian human-wave attacks and chemical weapons assaults launched by Iraq.
In July 1988, Khomeini accepted a UN brokered cease-fire, calling it “more deadly to me than poison”. But within days, members of the Iranian opposition group Mujahedeen-e-Khalq, heavily armed by Saddam, stormed across the Iranian border in a surprise attack.
Iran ultimately blunted their assault, but the attack set the stage for the sham retrials of political prisoners, militants and others that would become known as “death commissions”.
Some who appeared were asked to identify themselves. Those who responded “mujahedeen” were sent to their deaths, while others were questioned about their willingness to “clear minefields for the army of the Islamic Republic,” according to a 1990 Amnesty International report.
International rights groups estimate that as many as 5,000 people were executed, while the MEK puts the number at 30,000. Iran has never fully acknowledged the executions, apparently carried out on Khomeini’s orders, though some argue that other top officials were effectively in charge in the months before his death in 1989.
This month, a website run in Montazeri’s honour by his family released the audio. In it, the ayatollah apparently addresses prosecutors, a judge and an intelligence official over the executions, warning they will tarnish Khomeini’s image.
I believe that the biggest crime in the history of the Islamic Republic, which will be condemned by history, happened by your hands.Grand Ayatollah Hossein Ali Montazeri
He goes on to say that “fighting against ideology with killing is totally wrong”. He mentions the death of his son, Mohammad, in the 1981 bombing of the Islamic Republican Party’s headquarters in Tehran, which killed at least 72 people. Iran blamed the attack on the MEK, and the US State Department also has said the group was responsible for it.
“I got hurt more than anybody from them; they killed my son,” Montazeri says.
Family Faces Criticism for Releasing Audio
Shortly after the audio’s release, the website took it down. By that point, however, the clip had circulated online as Farsi-language media began reporting on it, sparking criticism of Montazeri’s family for releasing it.
My motivation for publishing this file, as I said for several times to many media, was to defend the truth and innocence of Ayatollah MontazeriAhmad Montazeri
The audio now has found its way into the wider conflict between Shiite power Iran and Sunni-ruled Saudi Arabia. Relations between the two nations soured in January after the kingdom executed a prominent Shiite cleric and angry demonstrators in Iran responded by attacking two Saudi diplomatic posts.
Saudi Arabia severed diplomatic ties with Iran over the attacks, though relations already were strained by the countries supporting opposing sides in Syria’s long war and the conflict in Yemen.
In the time since, state television in Saudi Arabia, which is among the world’s top executioners, repeatedly has aired a program about the 1988 executions in Iran, complete with a graphic of a figure hanging from the Iranian flag. It’s also aired video of Maryam Rajavi, the leader of the MEK’s political arm, throwing flower petals at pictures of those killed in the 1988 executions at an exhibition in Paris.
Prince Turki al-Faisal, Saudi Arabia’s former intelligence chief, appeared in July at a conference in Paris by the National Council of Resistance of Iran, the political affiliate of the MEK, which Rajavi leads. Al-Faisal’s involvement at the lavish ceremony brought a swift rebuke from Iran and raised questions about Saudi Arabia’s possible support of the group, which was listed as a terrorist organisation by the State Department for years over its killing of Americans.
The MEK says it renounced violence in 2001. The State Department removed the group from its list of terrorist organisations in 2012.
Asked about Saudi Arabia’s interest, the MEK said in a statement it “has not received financial help from the Saudi government or from any other government.” But it added that the real war gripping West Asia is “between the religious fascism ruling Iran on the one hand and the people of Iran and countries in the region on the other.”
(This article has been published in an arrangement with Associated Press.)
(At The Quint, we question everything. Play an active role in shaping our journalism by becoming a member today.)