The Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) on 5 January told the Supreme Court that despite the ban on sale of crackers in Delhi-NCR, air quality worsened in the national capital due to fireworks during Diwali in 2017.
A report submitted in the apex court said that as per a study carried out before and after Diwali, specific ill-effects of firecrackers couldn't be substantiated and a long-term study would be required.
The short-term study was conducted by experts entrusted by the CPCB at the time when sale of fire crackers was banned in Delhi-NCR by the top court from 9 October. It said that both PM 10 and PM 2.5 increased 2-3.5 fold on Diwali day in comparison to seven days before the festival.
The top pollution monitoring body told a bench comprising justices A K Sikri and Ashok Bhushan that in pursuance to the apex court order of 12 September last year, a study titled "Health Impact Assessment of Firecrackers Bursting during Dussehra and Diwali" was carried out.
The top court had last year constituted a committee, to be chaired by the chairperson of the CPCB, to conduct a research on the impact of the fire crackers during the festive season of Dussehra and Diwali on the health of people and submit a report by 31 December.
It said that on Diwali, sulphur dioxide and nitrogen dioxide level remained almost within prescribed limit.
Air quality did worsen during Diwali and symptoms of eye itching, increased coughing, relatively more hospital visits, increased noise levels and high metals in urine do reflect adverse impact of fire cracker bursting. However, it was not significant statistically.A long term study would be required to assess long term health impacts of firecracker bursting,CPCB Report
The pollution monitoring body said that although there was some increase in cough and breathlessness, but this did not translate into any significant illness requiring immediate medical attention.
Other system related complaints were also not much different during pre and post Dussehra and Diwali, it said.
There was evidence of increased values of barium and strontium in urine samples of many subjects. These are some of the metals used in fire cracker manufacturing.Increased levels in urine do reflect a probability of exposure. However, all other elements are not increased to substantiate the effect of bursting of crackers. It is also possible that the individuals were exposed due to bursting of fire crackers directly or indirectly in their locality,the CPCB said.
The top court had earlier taken the CPCB to task for not conducting any study on the harmful effects of materials used in the manufacture of fire crackers despite its directions, saying it was "really disturbed".
It had termed as "astonishing" that the board has not conducted a study or prepared a report on this aspect and said that government authorities have paid "very little or no attention" to the possible health hazards faced by children due to exposure to such chemicals.
The apex court had on 9 October last year said that no firecrackers would be sold in the Delhi-NCR during Diwali while banning its sale till 1 November, 2017.It had said that its earlier order, temporarily lifting the stay and permitting the sale of firecrackers, would be made effective only from 1 November.
The apex court, in its 9 October order, had said the 11 November, 2016 order suspending licences for sale of fireworks "should be given one chance to test itself" to see whether it had a positive effect, particularly during Diwali.
On 12 September this year, the top court had temporarily lifted its order suspending the permanent licences for sale of fire crackers in NCR, saying a complete ban would be an "extreme step" and a graded approach was needed to curb pollution caused by them.
The court, in its last year's direction, had suspended all licenses which permits sale of fireworks, wholesale and retail within the territory of NCR till further orders.
(Breathe In, Breathe Out: Are you finding it tough to breathe polluted air? Join hands with FIT in partnership with #MyRightToBreathe to find a solution to pollution. Send in your suggestions to fit@thequint.com or WhatsApp @ +919999008335)
(At The Quint, we question everything. Play an active role in shaping our journalism by becoming a member today.)