An emergency air-quality warning system created in 2016 for the national capital territory of Delhi has failed its sole purpose: To warn citizens of hazardous levels of air pollution.
Over eight days to 16 October 2017, as Delhi’s air quality worsened, reaching 10-12 times above safe limits set by the World Health Organisation (WHO), the government ignored its own plan, which also included a clean-up of the air. Officials should have, among other things, enforced pollution controls on thermal power plants, sprinkled water on roads to curb dust, and curbed traffic jams.
Over the last one month, Delhi residents should have received an alert every day, warning them that air quality index (AQI) readings were breaching danger levels. Since 8 October 2017, air-quality levels crossed “poor” eight times, “very poor to severe” 21 times, and “emergency” once, as they have for 48 hours to 8 November 2017, according to data from the government’s own alert system, the Graded Response Action Plan (GRAP).
The Government had enough time to implement GRAP and systematically issue health advisories as per the action plan guidelines. However, the effort to create public awareness, and alert the citizens to safeguard their health, only happened after reaching an emergency situation.Aishwarya Madineni, independent researcher
A Plan Ready to Be Implemented – Except It Was Not
After Delhi witnessed its worst smog in 17 years in 2016, the CPCB, under directions from the Supreme Court, submitted the GRAP to address the air-pollution crisis gripping the national capital region, particularly in winter.
While the ministry of environment, forests and climate change cleared the GRAP on 12 January 2017, the plan received approval from the nodal Environment Pollution Control Authority on 18 October 2017 – 10 months later.
Based on national air-quality index (AQI) readings generated by CPCB air-quality monitors, the GRAP system categorises pollution levels as “good” (AQI reading of 0-50), “satisfactory” (50-100), “moderate” (100-200), “poor” (200-300), “very poor” (300-400), and “severe” (400-500). Each grade of pollution involves curbs to prevent escalation. This is how it is supposed to work:
Graded Response Action Plan, By AQI Level
Poor (200-300 AQI):
- Cap emissions from thermal power plants;
- Sprinkling of water;
- Fine visibly polluting vehicles;
- Ensure smooth traffic movement;
- Implement Supreme Court’s ban on fireworks and entry of trucks registered post-2005
Very Poor (300-400 AQI)
- Ban diesel gensets;
- Increase parking fee;
- Increase metro service and fleet of buses;
- Ban open burning of firewood and coal for heating and cooking;
- Health advisory alert for vulnerable populations.
Severe (400-500 AQI)
- Shutdown Bardarpur power plant;
- Cap emissions from power plants in NCR;
- Close brick kilns, stone crushers and other polluting industries in NCR.
Emergency (500+ AQI)
- Stop entry of trucks into Delhi;
- Alert the task force for shutting down of schools and halt all outdoor activities for children.
An AQI reading of over 500 is considered to an “emergency”, and involves a shutdown of most outdoor activities. These measures are not new to authorities – they were recommended by a Indian Institute of Kanpur (IIT)-Kanpur report submitted to the Delhi government in January 2016, as IndiaSpend reported on 10 November 2016.
What The Government Should Have Done But Did Not
Air quality in Delhi began to dip from “moderate” to “poor” in the first week of October 2017 and proceeded to worsen.
Apart from curbing traffic, enforcing pollution standards on power plants and sprinkling water to curb dust, the government also should have made citizens aware of pollution levels using social media and mobile apps.
With the start of Diwali, air quality considerably worsened. From 17 October to 6 November 2017, the region recorded “very poor” air quality, 12-15 times above WHO limits, as we said.
On Diwali day, 20 October 2017, CPCB monitors in the national capital region recorded “severe” levels of pollution with an AQI reading of 403 – 16 times above WHO limits, suggesting poor implementation of the SC ban on firecrackers.
Over the last three weeks, government authorities, as per their own plan, should have also issued health advisory alerts for vulnerable populations or young children and senior citizens, banned use of diesel-run generators, raised parking fees, increased public transport services, and banned the use of firewood and coal.
Why GRAP Cannot Work Unless Various Agencies Work Together
To be successful, most components of the GRAP require concerted and coordinated efforts from various agencies and bodies spread across the national capital region (NCR) and neighbouring states.
“GRAP has an ambitious set of measures under each category of alerts to be issued with action extending to Haryana, Punjab and Uttar Pradesh. Yet, the system does not mention a proper mitigation plan for addressing crop fires across the NCR states, to which the evidence clearly attributes a 25 percent rise in the pollution levels,” said Madineni.
The fireworks ban for Diwali was also a complete eye wash, with little or no implementation bringing us to the emergency situation we are in today.Aishwarya Madineni, independent researcher
(This article was originally published on IndiaSpend. It has been republished with permission)
Breathe In, Breathe Out: Are you finding it tough to breathe polluted air? Join hands with FIT in partnership with #MyRightToBreathe to find a solution to pollution. Send in your suggestions to fit@thequint.com or WhatsApp @ +919999008335)
(At The Quint, we question everything. Play an active role in shaping our journalism by becoming a member today.)