A committee set up to submit an action plan for restoring the Yamuna floodplains, told the National Green Tribunal (NGT) on Friday that there was no compaction of the soil on the site where the Art of Living's (AOL) three-day cultural extravaganza was held in 2016.
The report assumes significance as its findings are different to that of an earlier seven-member expert panel, which had alleged that the Yamuna floodplains were completely destroyed due to the World Cultural Festival of AOL.
What the NGT Report Said
The three-member committee, which was formed by the NGT after submission of the report by the larger panel, said on Friday that the land where the AOL's event was held in 2016 was found to be fully covered with grass and some saplings of tree species.
The committee said in its report submitted before a bench headed by NGT Chairperson Justice Swatanter Kumar:
This kind of grass and natural regeneration of seedlings is not possible on compacted soil. “The area was also under water in small depressions in the majority of the areas where the function was held. No significant size of the wetland/water body was noticed by the committee in the area used by AOL.
Referring to Google earth images, the committee said in its report that it could not locate any "heap of debris" on the site, and it is evident that no "wetland or water body" was seen on the site prior to the event.
The report added, “The committee also inspected the areas on eastern bank which are under the control of UP government. This site, as informed by chief engineer, was used for parking of vehicles on 15 hectare land permitted by them to AOL temporarily for the event.”
Further, the report claimed:
He further informed the committee members that this land was being used by farmers for raising agricultural crops prior to the function, and at present also, the site is under agricultural crops.
The committee observed that no compaction of the soil was seen in this area as many portions were ploughed out where the soil was very loose and very healthy crops were standing on the ground. This is only possible if the soil is loose which can support the crop.
The panel comprises principal commissioner of DDA's horticulture department and chief engineers from the irrigation departments of Delhi and UP.
With regard to the removal of the toxins, which may have leached out of the dumped debris on the site, the panel said that two successive monsoons might have already washed away such material.
AOL Event Area Totally Destroyed
The panel said:
After the function of AOL, one monsoon season of 2016 is already over and monsoon season of 2017 is in progress, and it is expected that many of the toxic substances might have already been washed away.
It also added, “Anyway, toxification, if any, identified after the comparison of the testing of the soils of AOL site and the adjoining areas of the river, is proposed to be removed through the remediation methods.”
The committee has recommended against creation and maintenance of the wetlands within the Yamuna flood plain as such type of activity will also alter the natural flow of the river.
The matter is fixed for hearing on 4 August.
Earlier, an expert committee had told the tribunal that restoration of Yamuna floodplains, “ravaged” due to a cultural extravaganza organised by Sri Sri Ravi Shankar’s Art of Living in 2016, would cost Rs 42.02 crore besides additional ancillary expenses.
It had suggested that there would be two components in the rehabilitation plan – physical and biological – and they would cost Rs 28.73 crore and Rs 13.29 crore respectively.
The seven-member committee had observed that the entire floodplain area used for the main event site between DND flyover and the Barapulla drain (on the right bank of river Yamuna) had been completely destroyed, not simply damaged.
(We all love to express ourselves, but how often do we do it in our mother tongue? Here's your chance! This Independence Day, khul ke bol with BOL – Love your Bhasha. Sing, write, perform, spew poetry – whatever you like – in your mother tongue. Send us your BOL at bol@thequint.com or WhatsApp it to 9910181818.)
(At The Quint, we question everything. Play an active role in shaping our journalism by becoming a member today.)