Disposable Sanitary Napkins Mess Up Both Health and Environment

Commercial disposable sanitary napkins pose health hazards due to its chemical cocktail content.

Long-lasting, comfortable, stain-free and affordable – these are the thoughts that come to every woman's mind when she picks up a disposable sanitary napkin.

What doesn't occur to most women is that over a billion of these non-compostable sanitary pads are making their way into sewerage systems, landfills, fields and water bodies in India every month, posing huge environmental and health risks.

With taboos and superstitions galore about menstruating women in India, safe technologies and interventions to dispose of and treat menstrual waste have become a huge challenge.

1,13,000 tonnes

Though the Indian government is ensuring that all women and girls, especially in rural pockets, have easy access to sanitary napkins, the need of the hour, say experts IANS spoke to, is to give “more attention” to managing menstrual waste, which is estimated to be 1,13,000 tonnes annually.

Menstrual Hygiene Management – A Neglected Issue?

Perhaps realising the growing problem of menstrual waste, the Narendra Modi government came out with new Solid Waste Management (SWM) rules in 2016.

These rules makes it obligatory for the manufacturers, brand owners or marketing companies of sanitary napkins and diapers to provide a pouch or a wrapper for their safe disposal.

But that doesn't seem to be enough.

Myles Ellege, Senior Director at RTI International, a leading non-profit applied research and consulting organisation based in North Carolina, US, said although some Indian states and cities have given "some attention" to waste segregation or waste management with incinerators at schools or institutional settings, "it is not widespread".

The issue of managing menstrual waste is one that needs more attention... MHM (Menstrual Hygiene Management) is a neglected issue, and disposal is probably the most neglected topic in the MHM value chain.

Myles Ellege, Senior Director, RTI International

Weak Solid Waste Management Rules

According to Shradha Shreejaya, an active campaigner in Sustainable Menstruation Kerala Collective, a Kerala-based NGO that promotes biodegradable and toxin-free sanitary products, "India has been very messy about dealing with its sanitary waste..." and described the new rules as "very weak".

We have found ignorance regarding the raw materials used in making most sanitary products that are falsely assumed to be only cotton and plastic – the products are more than 90 percent plastic, with super absorbent polymers and non-woven plastic components, that make it extremely difficult to dispose of it in a backyard, the shortcut way.

Shradha Shreejaya

Shradha Shreejaya is also a supporter of EcoFemme, which manufactures and promotes reusable cloth pads.

Arundati Muralidharan, Manager-Policy (WASH in Health and Nutrition, WASH in Schools) at WaterAid India, an international charity that works in the area of water, sanitation and hygiene services, said the government has menstrual waste "very much" on its radar and has been "thinking" about its management.

If we do not begin to address this issue now, we will have a large volume of non-biodegradable waste that will take hundreds of years to degrade. 

Arundati Muralidharan, Manager-Policy, WaterAid India

A Major Health Hazard

336 million girls and women

According to a survey, about 336 million girls and women experience menstruation in India, which means that approximately 121 million of them are using disposable sanitary napkins.

In a survey, Path, a global leader in innovations – which works with industries, governments and other stakeholders, to bridge gaps between the supply and demand of quality products, and is currently working on testing a hybrid reusable sanitary pad – estimated that over a billion of these non-compostable pads are being dumped in landfills and sewerage systems.

Most women in big cities and towns go for commercial disposable sanitary napkins (DSN), not knowing that some of these products pose health hazards due to its chemical cocktail content (dioxin, furan, pesticides and other endocrine disruptors), said experts.

With no knowledge of how to dispose of them, most women just throw them in the garbage bin, which usually gets mixed up with dry, wet and hazardous waste.

Apart from the fact that it cannot be recycled, the exposed sanitary napkin poses grave health risks for the waste collector.

The problem does not end here. The plastic layer which is used to make it stain-free, and the chemicals used in producing it, get further transferred between soil, water and air, experts added.

Most women and girls in rural India use cloth, which, if not dried in proper sunlight for reuse, could lead to further health complications.

Alternate Solution?

In fact, many women in rural India tend to throw them in open spaces like rivers, wells and even roadsides as they don’t have access to safe options.

Activists are advocating using reusable eco-friendly sanitary pads, including cloth pads, biodegradable pads and cups.

According to Manish Malani, co-founder of She Cups, they came to know about menstrual cups when they were looking for economical diagnostic kits for cervical cancer patients.

Good menstrual hygiene practices keep the body healthy, thereby less vulnerable to infections/diseases.

Manish Malani

As innovation is the key to this issue, Ellege said they are “working to design waste handling and treatment systems that will process the waste, and potentially use the by-products as mechanism for advancing waste-to-energy technology solutions on-site.”

(This piece has been published in an arrangement with IANS)

(Kavita Bajeli-Datt can be contacted at [e-mail]. This is an opinion piece and the views expressed above are the author’s own. The Quint neither endorses nor is responsible for the same.)