"I am done with Kangana playing the victim card at every given point of time with a sad story to tell about being terrorised by the bad people in the industry; if it’s so bad, leave it”, pronounced Bollywood director Karan Johar at a public venue earlier this year.
The pompous declaration came in response to a statement by the national award winning actress Kangana Ranaut accusing him of the being ‘the flag-bearer of nepotism’ on his popular talk show Koffee With Karan.
Ranaut had touched a raw nerve by daring to address the touchy subject of nepotism in a country where social mobility can be unimaginably difficult without the right pedigree or connections.
“The Indian film industry is not a small studio given to Karan by his father when he was in his early 20s”, responded Kangana. “That is just a small molecule… He is nobody to tell me to leave it. I'm definitely not going anywhere, Mr Johar."
What is important to understand is that we are not fighting people, we are fighting a mentality. I am not fighting Karan Johar, I am fighting male chauvinism.Kangana Ranaut
Simmering with resentment at having been told off by the impertinent outsider, Johar along with star kids Varun Dhawan and Saif Ali Khan churlishly yelled out ‘Nepotism Rocks’ at the IIFA Film Awards in New York. This was followed by tacky barbs at Ranaut, perhaps to be expected from hacks known for a string of tawdry, regressive films like Race 2, Humshakals, Kuch Kuch Hota Hai, among others.
To make matters worse, Khan published a tone-deaf article to explain where he was coming from, displaying a total disconnect from reality.
I think it’s extremely relevant in a conversation on nepotism, which means family favouritism, to talk about genetics and eugenics. Eugenics means well born and in a movie context, the genes of, let’s say Dharmendra’s son or Amitabh Bachchan’s son or for that matter, Sharmila Tagore’s son come into play. So yes, maybe I got a chance because of my mother, but that is more genetics than nepotism. It’s a genetic investment that the producer was making.Saif Ali Khan
Eugenics – or controlled breeding - was once touted by Adolf Hitler and scientists employed by the Nazi regime as an effective means to maintain racial purity in Germany - by weeding out contaminants like Jews, Gypsies and other “undesirable” breeds. Eugenicists have much in common with modern day white supremacists who believe that blacks, hispanics and other non-white races are genetically predisposed to criminality, high drop-out rates and poor academic performance, and are therefore a burden on society and a threat to western civilisation, culture and values.
In the Indian context, classical eugenics would translate to perpetuation of Brahminism and the caste system.
But it didn’t stop there. Khan continued to embarrass himself with comments so ludicrous they would have put paid to his career anywhere but India, where privilege and entitlement are seen as the natural order of things:
If you need another example, then take race horses. We take a derby winner, mate him with the right mate and see if we can create another grand national winner. So, in that sense, this is the relationship between genetics and star kids.Saif Ali Khan
Khan then dug himself into a deeper ditch (as if that was possible) by claiming that Aristocracy meant “the rule of the best, which is what this industry is. Ruled by the best”. Er, no Mr. Khan. Aristocracy refers to the highest class in certain societies, especially those holding (unearned) hereditary titles or offices, an apt description for Khan, Johar and their ilk.
It did not take long for the irrepressible Ranaut to respond.
I fail to understand how you can compare genetically hybrid racehorses to artistes! Are you implying that artistic skills, hard work, experience, concentration spans, enthusiasm, eagerness, discipline and love, can be inherited through family genes? If your point was true, I would be a farmer back home.Kangana Ranaut
This hackneyed reality show playing out on social media and the blogosphere is emblematic of a much larger malaise. The ingrained nepotism and entitlement in all spheres of Indian life have led to abysmally low standards and the general lack of accountability that we see all around us; in the arts, politics and business.
Auteurs with stunningly original ideas languish for years before their efforts are recognised, and often fall by the wayside in sheer despair, while connected insiders secure plum gigs on the strength of their name alone.
It is a sad day when bonafide global celebrities like Bill Gates, Bono, George Clooney, Meryl Streep and others devote their time and resources to empowerment of the underprivileged, while our Indian poseurs unabashedly declare their contempt for the same.
When Karan Johar said his job was not to nurture talent, but only to grow his legacy, he was merely echoing the sentiments of those, who like him, believe that they have no responsibility to society at large, only to themselves. Until this mindset changes, the outlook for all realms of public life, and not just entertainment, remains bleak in India.
(We all love to express ourselves, but how often do we do it in our mother tongue. Here's your chance! This Independence Day, khul ke bol with BOL – Love your Bhasha. Sing, write, perform, spew poetry – whatever you like – in your mother tongue. Send us your BOL at bol@thequint.com or WhatsApp it to 9910181818.)
(At The Quint, we question everything. Play an active role in shaping our journalism by becoming a member today.)