Why Did the Election Commission Not Defer Union Budget 2017?

If the EC can stop the government from announcing state-specific schemes, can’t it defer the budget till elections?

The EC has direcetd the government to refrain from announcing state-specific schemes in Budget 2017. Representative Image. (Photo Courtesy: Twitter/@PIB_India)

The Election Commission (EC) has directed the government to refrain from announcing any state-specific scheme in the Union Budget 2017, that may influence voters in the five poll-bound states.

Also Read: EC Announces Dates of Assembly Polls 2017 in Five States

The Commission, however, stopped short of asking the Narendra Modi government to defer the Budget till the conclusion of assembly elections in Uttar Pradesh, Uttarakhand, Punjab, Goa and Manipur.

So what prompted the poll panel, an independent, autonomous body, to take a rather cautious approach towards the Budget and merely restrain the government from announcing sops for the five states?

A highly placed source in the poll panel told IANS that the Commission did not want to be seen acting outside its mandate.

"We considered the matter carefully. There were several considerations," the source, privy to the discussions, told IANS.

The official said it was primarily the government's prerogative to present the Budget when it wanted.

"Our role is limited to seeing that the voters are not influenced by any means," the source added.

But if the EC can restrain the government from announcing sops, can it not stop the government from presenting the Budget altogether until the elections get over?

We don’t have such sweeping powers. We only act under the Model Code of Conduct (MCC) and MCC is just a moral power.

Source close to the government

The official mentioned the 2009 advisory the EC issued during the Lok Sabha election.

In a letter to Chief Secretaries and Chief Electoral Officers of all states and Union Territories dated 9 March 2009, the EC wrote:

The Commission would like to point out the prevalent convention that is followed in most states is that instead of presenting the full budget, only a vote on account is taken for 3-4 months in cases where a general election is imminent or when the MCC is in operation. It contributes to a healthy democratic process.

The official said the EC took a similar stand this time too. So, instead of prescribing a course of action, it left it to the "sense of propriety" of the government.

Did the Supreme Court's observation on Monday also weigh on the EC?

"Well, no," said the source. "We operate on a different plane. We operate around the MCC and do not examine the legal aspects."

But what if the government, instead of mentioning a particular state, announces sops which apply to every state, such as rebate in income tax or other steps which apply to all Indians? Won't it influence the voters?

"Let's see," the official said.

Also Read:
What the Market Expects From Arun Jaitley’s Union Budget 2017
First Budget Since Demonetisation: What We Can Expect
Budget 2017: Will a 3% Fiscal Deficit Remain Elusive?