Wow! PMO Made Irani’s Circular on Fake News Look Like Fake News
PM Narendra Modi withdrew Smriti Irani’s diktat on fake news 15 hours after she had issued it.
advertisement
Video Editor: Vivek Gupta
All those journalists who consider their pens to be mightier than swords, lend me your ears. Katha Zor Garam – or hot news – is that in the era of fake news, your PIB accreditation is in danger. The accreditation, which is issued by the Press Information Bureau (PIB), is proof of you being a journalist. In simple words, it is the Aadhaar card for journalists.
The responsibility to identify what constitutes fake news was given to the Press Council of India (PCI) and the News Broadcasters Association (NBA) for newspaper and television channels, respectively.
Once the complaint is registered, the journalist would lose his or her accreditation till the PCI or NBA don’t complete their investigation to determine whether the journalist is guilty.
The PCI or the NBA must complete their investigation within 15 days. As per the circular:
But what about the the ministers in the Modi government and their staff who spread fake news? Who will determine the punishment for them? Well, I have a few ideas.
Modi’s Chennai Flood Gaffe
Do you remember this photo?
In December 2015, during the Chennai floods, Prime Minister Narendra Modi was photographed taking an ariel tour of the flood affected city. This photo was released by the PIB then, the same PIB that is charged with the responsibility to issue an accreditation to a journalist. But this image turned out to be fake.
The actual photo was this.
After receiving a lot of flak online, the fake photo was removed from the PIB’s official handle. So, the punishment for the PIB for this gaffe should be that they must enrol at a media institute and take up a three-month crash course in media ethics.
Harsh Vardhan’s Hawking Faux Pas
Dr Harsh Vardhan made a shocking claim that one of the most accomplished minds in human history, Stephen Hawking, had said that the theory in the Vedas was superior to Einstein’s theory of relativity – or E=mc2. Till date, no credible source has validated this claim.
The faux pas becomes even more glaring when you realise that Harsh Vardhan is a surgeon and currently handles the portfolios of Union Science and Technology and Earth Sciences Minister in the Modi government.
So, Dr Vardhan, your punishment for spreading this fake news should be that you be addressed as quack for 15 days.
Former Army Chief Falls for Fake News
In December 2017, a video of Major Prafulla in Rajouri sector went viral. Former chief of army staff and current Minister of State for External Affairs General VK Singh posted this video from his personal Facebook account.
As it turned out later, the video was seven years old. So, for circulating this fake news, the punishment for General Singh should be that he is free to tour and travel to foreign nations but he won’t be able to enter his Ghaziabad constituency for 30 days.
Science of a Cow Exhaling Oxygen
In January 2017, Rajasthan’s Education Minister Vasudev Devnani made an outlandish assertion that the cow is the only animal that inhales as well as exhales oxygen.
So Mr Devnanai, your punishment should be that for the next 15 days, you will have to breathe the same oxygen that is exhaled by cows.
How will we determine whether a politician or a minister has made a fake statement? Well, on the lines of the PCI and the NBA, we can set up a fake news cell under the Election Commission.
Alas, before we could implement these punishments, PM Modi withdrew Smirti Irani’s fake news diktat. The order issued by the Prime Minister’s Office read:
In other words, the PMO order has rendered Smriti Irani’s circular on fake news moot and, to a certain extent, fake.
(This story was originally published on Quint Hindi)
(At The Quint, we question everything. Play an active role in shaping our journalism by becoming a member today.)