‘Rewriting History Is the Historian’s Job, Not Anyone Else’s’: Swapna Liddle

Swapna Liddle says, "Rewriting history is not the problem. But this is the job of a historian."

"The fact that a place of worship was destroyed many centuries ago, does that mean that a place of worship should be destroyed today?" asks historian Swapna Liddle.

(Photo: Chetan Bhakuni/The Quint)

Video Editor: Purnendu Pritam

"The fact that these are being demolished is a cause of concern. Particularly since many of these are not only historic, but they are also, by law, listed as heritage buildings," said historian Swapna Liddle after the centuries-old Akhunji mosque in Delhi's Mehrauli was demolished by the Delhi Development Authority on 31 January.

Liddle sat down to chat with The Quint at the 17th edition of the Jaipur Literature Festival held between 1-5 February 2024.

Read the edited excerpts below.

The Akhunji mosque in Delhi's Mehrauli was demolished and this is not the first time a mosque has been demolished in recent history. Can you talk to us about the demolition and the cultural impact it might have?

Mehrauli is an area which is very rich in old monuments. There are many historic graveyards, mosques, and dargahs of various saints. Some of them date back to very early periods, starting from the early 13th century, and coming down to even the 19th century. 

The fact that these are being demolished is a cause of concern. Particularly since many of these are not only historic, but are also, by law, listed as heritage buildings. That is something that should be looked at. 

Which are the buildings that have been demolished? What was their legal status? Many of these are legally protected.

Many of these buildings are living heritage sites also. These are associated with the current beliefs and practices of the people who are living around them. 

Some of them are revered by people who come from outside as well. These are important cultural spaces, tied up with a lot of social and religious beliefs. That definitely has a very big impact on the lives of people.

Can you comment on the way places of worship were destroyed in history versus in the present day?

When I talk about history, I will look at the context in which temples were destroyed, which were invariably political contexts, which took place many hundred years ago. 

The question remains as to how today, in the 21st century, we should be approaching the past and how we want to move forward from that. 

The fact that a place of worship was destroyed many centuries ago, does that mean that a place of worship should be destroyed today?

What is it like to be a historian in such tumultuous times?

Rewriting history is not the problem. It is the job of a historian. This is the job of someone who has the training.

It’s become fashionable to dismiss historians today – either historians don’t know anything, or there is a conspiracy theory that they are trying to hide things, or tell you lies. That’s not true.

They are the ones who have that knowledge to be able to advance our understanding of the past.