Must Apologise to Indian Academia for Insults: Congress to Jaitley

Manish Tewari (left) Arun Jaitley (right) (Photo: The Quint)

Congress on Monday demanded that Finance Minister Arun Jaitley apologise for "insulting" the Indian academia with his remark at the London School of Economics (LSE) that "there is an alliance of subversion on Indian campuses".

Jaitley said this on Saturday in reference to last week's violence at Ramjas College of Delhi University.

Senior Congress leader P Chidambaram took a dig at Jaitley.

Also Read: Ramjas Row- Where’s Academic Freedom in Times of Campus Politics?

The Congress also accused the government of justifying the violence on the campus and said this was nothing but "fascist in nature".

At a media conference, Congress spokesperson Manish Tewari said:

The Finance Minister went to London. At LSE, he said ‘there is an alliance of subversion across university campuses in India’. Thus spoke the Finance Minister in the erstwhile capital of Imperial Britain. He has insulted the academia of India, insulted its students, teachers and other members of the fraternity. He (Jaitley) should apologise for the language he has used against the Indian academia and that too on foreign soil.

Jaitley’s Allegation

Delivering a talk at the LSE on Saturday, Jaitley had said:

Violence is not the method; no group can and should use violence...there is an alliance of subversion which is taking place. The separatists and the ultra-Left are speaking the same language in certain university campuses. So, they must be willing to allow others with a different opinion to put a counter viewpoint.

Jaitley's comment came days after violent clashes outside Ramjas College between activists of the Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad – the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh's students wing – and the left-wing All India Students Association (AISA) on 22 February.

Tewari also said Jaitley's remarks reflected the deep-seated fear in the BJP that there was an instinctive alliance of subversion coming together.

Also Read: DU Professor Beaten at Ramjas Protests, Suffers Internal Injuries

“Freedom of Expression Includes the Right to Offend”

That instinctive alliance of subversion is predicated on undermining the fascist principle, which is intrinsic to the BJP. That is the alliance which challenges their intolerance and their right to dominate the discourse which is making the government paranoid.

"The violence which took place in Ramjas College is absolutely abhorrent. What is more shocking, is the attempts made by seniors in the government to justify the violence.

Tewari later added:

Nobody holds the brief for the balkanisation of India or supports those who advocate the secession of India. The Right to Freedom of Expression includes the right to offend and those offended have recourse to the law, if the reasonable restrictions are in any manner transgressed.

Accusing the Modi government of joining forces with the Sangh Parivar to unleash assaults on Indian democracy, Tewari also said the assault on students and teachers by the ABVP activists at Ramjas College was part of a concerted effort by the right-wing forces.

The incident (at Ramjas) is not isolated. Ever since this government came to power, attempts have been on to adjust the discourse 90 degrees to the right. There is this pattern of intimidation and violence going on across the country, which challenges the fundamental precept on which the Constitution of India rests, the idea on which the country has been founded. 

"Therefore, time has come for all progressive, pluralistic and patriotic forces to come together and fight this relentless assault on Indian democracy by elements of the Sangh Parivar...(that) has complete and absolute backing of the government right up to the Prime Minister," said Tewari.

Also Read: Won’t Let DU Become JNU- How Ramjas Echoes of JNU of Feb 2016

Earlier, Trinamool Congress leader Derek O'Brien had said that Modi was following on Twitter certain trolls who write "venomous, misogynist" stuff besides issuing "murderous threats".

The clashes at Ramjas between the two groups erupted after the ABVP forced cancellation of a seminar that was to be addressed by JNU student Umar Khalid. Khalid was jailed last year on sedition charges for allegedly shouting anti-India slogans.

The discord took a new turn after Gurmehar Kaur, a student of Lady Shri Ram College and daughter of an army officer killed in the Kargil war, launched a social media campaign against the ABVP.

Kaur posted a photo in social media, holding a placard saying "I am a student of Delhi University. I am not afraid of ABVP. I am not alone. Every student of India is with me," with hashtag #studentsagainstabvp.