Amit Shah, Nitish Kumar Bonhomie on Display Amid Reports of Tussle

There’s speculation of strained ties between the BJP and JD(U), primarily over the issue of seat sharing.

Bihar CM Nitish Kumar and BJP President Amit Shah exchange greetings at the state guest house, in Patna on Thursday, July 12.

(Photo: PTI)

Over a decade after a cancelled dinner invitation by Nitish Kumar for BJP leaders broke a long-running alliance at that time, the Bihar Chief Minister on Thursday, 12 July hosted the saffron party’s Chief Amit Shah for breakfast as well as dinner in what is being seen as an attempt to dispel rumblings about differences in a revived alliance.

After breakfast, seen by political observers as an ice breaker amid talks in some corners about growing differences over seat sharing for Lok Sabha polls next year, Kumar and Shah met again over dinner signalling all was well in the National Democratic Alliance (NDA).

As per the two party leaders, they held wide-ranging talks on the current political situation in Bihar and the NDA's strategy for contesting the 40 seats in the state in the upcoming Lok Sabha polls.

Sources in both parties said the two leaders have broadly covered the ground situation in three different regions of Bihar - north, south and Seemanchal - the last having several seats with a sizeable number of minority votes.

Carrying forward the display of bonhomie over breakfast, Shah and Kumar joined by some other state level leaders of JD(U) and BJP met over dinner at CM’s official bungalow for dinner.

Besides, Shah, from BJP Deputy Chief Minister Sushil Kumar Modi, Bihar party Chief Nityanand Rai, state ministers – Nand Kishore Yadav and Mangal Pandey – joined their JD(U) colleagues RCP Singh, Rajiv Ranjan Singh Lallan, Bijendra Yadav and state party chief Basistha Narayan Singh.

Dispelling Seat Sharing Rumblings

Kumar and Shah first met over breakfast for about an hour and later over dinner during the first visit of Shah to Bihar after return of Kumar's JD(U) to the NDA.

In between Shah held talks with state BJP leaders for a feedback on ground level situation in different Lok Sabha constituencies in the state.

Neither side briefed the media on the areas covered during the two rounds of talks and on whether any formula for seat sharing was in the process of being evolved.

Shah while addressing BJP workers function, however, dismissed about Kumar being uncomfortable in the NDA and asserted that he was not going to side with those tainted with corruption charges, an obvious reference to the main opposition RJD-Congress combine.

Broadly covering ground situation in three regions of North, South and Seemanchal, sources said the BJP wanted the JD(U) to play a significant role in Seemanchal comprising Kisanganj, Araria, Katihar and Purnea districts considering Kumar’s appeal among the minorities.

The JD(U), at its recent national executive meeting in Delhi, had authorized Kumar who is also the party president to reach any decision on seat sharing and has made it clear that he would say anything on the issue only when an offer of seats has been made to his party.

JD(U) had contested 25 out of 40 seats in 2009, but in 2014 when he broke away from the NDA, the alliance without him won 31 of the 40 seats.

An honourable and acceptable formula for seat-sharing would make demands for sacrifices on either side. After his talks here, Shah is also likely to discuss the issue of seat-sharing with other NDA constituents, LJP and RLSP, led by Union ministers Ram Vilas Paswan and Upendra Kushwaha respectively before any formula for seat sharing is mooted by the BJP.

Both Paswan and Kushwaha are out of the country and no representative from their parties was seen at the venue. This is Shah's first visit to the state since the dramatic political realignment of last year when Kumar, the JD(U) national president, walked out of the Grand Alliance which included the RJD and Congress, and returned to the NDA.

The display of bonhomie between the tall leaders over Breakfast as well dinner is in stark contrast to cancellation of a dinner by Kumar for BJP leaders in 2010, an event that ultimately precipitated into the JD(U) walking out of the coalition in July 2013, ending 17 years of association.

Kumar had cancelled the dinner that year after a photograph of him holding hands with then Gujarat chief minister Narendra Modi appeared in a number of local newspapers.

After snapping over a decade-long ties with the BJP in 2013, Kumar returned to the NDA fold last year. The JD(U) had performed dismally in the 2014 Lok Sabha polls, when it won only two seats. However, in the assembly elections that were held the following year, it won 71 seats, more than the combined tally of all the other NDA constituents.