EC Orders Probe After Congress Complains of PM Modi’s “Roadshow”

BJP vs Congress on the Model Code of Conduct.

The Quint
India
Updated:
The results for the Gujarat Assembly elections will be declared on 18 December.
i
The results for the Gujarat Assembly elections will be declared on 18 December.
(Photo: The Quint)

advertisement

The BJP and Congress have accused each other of violating the Model Code of Conduct. The Congress has also accused the Election Commission of “working under pressure from PM and Prime Minister’s Office”. On 13 December, the EC issued a notice to Congress president-elect Rahul Gandhi, over his interviews to television networks one day before the final phase of voting in Gujarat.

On its part, the Congress has alleged that a “subservient” Election Commission allowed PM Modi to hold a ‘roadshow’ after casting his vote in Ahmedabad on 14 December.

  • EC orders probe after Congress complained against PM Modi’s “roadshow”
  • Congress has accused PM Modi of violating Model Code of Conduct by holding a ‘roadshow’ after voting in Ahmedabad
  • EC directed that an FIR be filed against channels in the state that telecast Rahul Gandhi’s interview 48 hours before the polls
  • The EC also issued notice to Gandhi, asking for an explanation by 18 December
  • Congress demanded that FIRs be filed against PM Modi, other BJP leaders

EC Orders Probe After Cong Complains of PM's "Roadshow"

After the Congress took exception to PM Modi’s “roadshow”, the party lodged a complaint with the Election Commission and the Chief Electoral Officer of Gujarat on 14 December. A separate complaint was also submitted to the Ranip Police.

In response to the Congress's complaint, Chief Electoral Officer of Gujarat BB Swain said an inquiry has been ordered to probe whether there was any violation of the Model Code of Conduct (MCC).

The complaint was more “anticipatory in nature”, he said.

have received a complaint regarding MCC violation after casting of vote (by Modi). It was more anticipatory in nature. It said there was a huge crowd (outside the polling booth) and it could turn into a roads
BB Swain

“We have handed over the inquiry to the Ahmedabad district election officer (the district collector). Since our MCC team was also present at the booth, it will also give its report. They (the collector and MCC team) are now finalising their overall inquiry report,” Swain said.

PM Modi Facing Crisis of Credibility, Says Rahul Gandhi

Congress president-elect Rahul Gandhi lashed out at Prime Minister Narendra Modi, alleging that he was facing a "crisis of credibility" and had stopped talking of corruption.

Speaking at a massive rally of congress workers in Thiruvananthapuram, Gandhi said people no longer believe in what he (Modi) says.

Today three years after he came to power, prime minister Modi is facing a crisis of credibility .People listen to his speeches, but no longer believe in what he says. The reason for this is his actions and the performance of his government in the last three years

Gandhi said the prime minister had committed to the youth of the country that he will get two crore jobs every year for them. He had also laid out a vision of Make-in India, Start-up India and Connect India.

The prime minister had also challenged China's dominance in manufacturing, Gandhi said.

"However, today the truth was out. We asked the government some time back how many jobs have been created under the Make-in-India, Startup india and connect India programmes," he said.

"No FIR Against Rahul": Election Commission

The Election Commission today said that no FIR had been lodged against Rahul Gandhi for giving an interview on 13 December, and that he had only been served a notice.

Last night, a Congress delegation met EC over several allegations made by them. EC deliberated and wrote to CEO to submit his report by mid-day today; the matter is under examination and under due deliberation. No FIR has been lodged against Rahul Gandhi, he has only been issued a notice under model code of conduct and given 5 days time to respond to it

Talking about PM Modi’s submarine launch, the EC said that it did not fall under the jurisdiction of the Model Code of Conduct.

BJP delegation came to office today and they kept some points related to allegations made by Congress. The Commission will consider and after due diligence take a decision.

Don't See Any Code of Conduct Being Violated: S Kashyap

Constitution expert S Kashyap said he did not see any violation of code of conduct on part of PM Modi, when he came in to cast his vote.

PM didn’t campaign for his party, he did not utter a single word but only showed his finger with an ink mark which can be interpreted as to send a message to people vote and not who to vote for.

Very Concerned Over EC's Double Standards: Shashi Tharoor

Reacting to PM Modi’s ‘roadshow’, Congress MP Shashi Tharoor said that the EC’s obvious condoning of the BJP’s ‘blatant violation of the election code’ is astonishing.

The EC has lost all objectivity and impartiality. We are truly shocked by this behaviour. 

BJP Delegation Leaves EC Office

The BJP delegation led by Nirmala Sitharaman and Ravi Shankar PRasad left the Election Commission in Delhi, after meeting with the Chief Election Officer.

Have Received a Complaint Against PM Modi: Gujarat CEO

Addressing a press conference, Gujarat Chief Election Officer BB Swain said that the EC had received a complaint on PM Modi’s roadshow.

We have received a complaint regarding MCC violation after casting of the vote. It is a complaint which is more anticipatory in nature, and says the crowd was there and this could be a roadshow. This complaint has been given to DEO Ahmedabad.

Swain said that the MCC team was also present at the time, and that they were finalising the enquiry report.

Police Detains Protesting Congress Workers

The police detained Congress workers who were marching to Election Commission in protest over PM Modi's roadshow after casting his vote today.

The protesters were stopped by police outside Sardar Patel Bhawan near Patel Chowk in Delhi .

BJP Delegation Heads to EC: Reports

According to TV channels, a BJP delegation led by Nirmala Sitharaman, Ravi Shankar Prasad, Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi, PP Chaudhary and Arun Singh heading to Election Commission. The delegation will reportedly meet officials regarding the Congress’ press conference.

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Condemn Congress' Allegations Against EC: BJP

BJP’s Bhupendra Yadav condemned the Congress for calling the EC a ‘captive puppet’ of the BJP-run government. Referring to the earlier-held Rajya Sabha elections, Yadav said:

<i>Pichle Rajya Sabha chunaav ke dauran jab chunav aayog ne nirnaye diya tha, humne use sweekar kiya tha. Congress ne tab isi chunaav aayog ko nishpaksh kaha tha.</i>

EC Is PM's Captive Puppet: Congress

The Congress slammed what they called a “subservient” Election Commission after Prime Minister Narendra Modi held a ‘roadshow’ after casting his vote in Ahmedabad on 14 December.

The party said that the ‘roadshow’ is a clear violation of the Model Code of Conduct and that the poll body “seems to working under pressure from PM and Prime Minister’s Office.”

Congress spokesperson Randeep Surjewala called the EC a “captive puppet of the PM” which has turned into “BJP’s frontal organisation.”

“The Chief Election Officer has abdicated his responsibility and as the Prime Minister faces an imminent defeat, he is now latching on to the last straw of the EC... We had sought an appointment with the EC at 4:30 pm yesterday (13 December) and they kept deferring it. When we told them that we will sit in a dharna outside their office, they relented and called us at 10:15 pm. It shows how prejudiced and one-sided the EC is. This has not happened in 70 years,” Surjewala told reporters.

The Congress has also filed an official complaint against the PM for holding the ‘roadshow’.

BJP Petitioning EC Is Act of Desperation: Chidambaram

Senior Congress leader and former Union Minister P Chidambaram lashed out at the BJP “petitioning” the Election Commission over Rahul Gandhi’s interview. He called the BJP’s move an “act of desperation”.

BJP Files Complaint Against Bharatsinh Solanki

The BJP alleged that Gujarat Congress leader Bharatsinh Solanki appeared on television channel on 13 December, and said that the voters responded “well” to the party in the first phase. This was a violation of the Model Code of Conduct, alleged the party.

In a statement, the BJP said, “Shri Bharatsinh Solanki appeared on TV on Wednesday, and said that voters have responded to us in phase one, and we hope they will also respond in phase two polling, and thereby appealed to the people to vote for INC. This is a total violation of the Conduct of Election Rules and Section 126 of the RP Act 1951, and an offence whatsoever as contemplated under the provisions of section 126 of the Representations of Peoples Act 1951 can said to have been committed”.

File FIR Against PM Modi, Other BJP Leaders: Surjewala

A Congress delegation reached the Election Commission office in Delhi late on Wednesday night and told media that “PM Modi, BJP President Amit Shah, Finance Minister Arun Jaitley and Railway Minister Piyush Goyal have violated the Model Code of Conduct over and over again.”

They also alleged that the PM has misused the Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FICCI) platform to attack the Congress, and that the EC should stay “unbiased”.

The Congress also submitted a memorandum to the EC demanding registration of FIRs against BJP leaders for “violating” the Model Code of Conduct.

In 2014 elections, PM Modi even showed the BJP symbol on voting day, but the EC did not act. The BJP held a press conference just before the first phase of Gujarat elections. These double standards won’t work, and first an FIR should be filed against Modi and other BJP leaders instead of the press.
Randeep Surjewala, Congress Spokesperson

Randeep Surjewala said the EC acted against news channels for airing the interview of Rahul Gandhi which was against the freedom of expression guaranteed by the Constitution.

Here is the Congress memorandum:

(Photo Courtesy: @rssurjewala/Twitter)
(Photo Courtesy: @rssurjewala/Twitter)

EC Issues Notice to Rahul Gandhi

The Election Commission on 13 December issued notice to Rahul Gandhi for interviews given by him and aired by TV networks, one day prior to the final phase of polling in the Gujarat elections.

Explain why action should not be taken against you for violating provisions of Model Code of Conduct, failing which Commission will decide on the matter without any further reference to you.
Election Commission to Rahul Gandhi

EC Directs Gujarat Election Chief to File FIR Against TV Networks

The Election Commission on Wednesday, 13 December, directed the Gujarat Chief Election Officer BB Swain to file an FIR against channels in Gujarat that telecast Rahul Gandhi’s interview, one day prior to the final phase of polling in the state.

We Will Examine Interview DVDs for Violation: Swain

Gujarat Chief Election Officer BB Swain said that they have collected the DVDs of Rahul Gandhi’s interviews to TV channels, and that they will be examining them for violation.

We have collected the DVDs and will be doing due examination to check whether it has violated Rules 126 RP Act or not.
BB Swain

EC Will Take Cognisance of Interviews: Piyush Goyal

Hitting out at Rahul Gandhi for giving an interview just a day ahead of the second phase of polling, Union Minister Piyush Goyal said that the Election Commission would take cognisance of it.

It was not permitted to give an interview in the last 48 hours of campaigning in Gujarat. I am sure the Election Commission will take cognisance of this and take action.
Piyush Goyal

(At The Quint, we question everything. Play an active role in shaping our journalism by becoming a member today.)

Published: 13 Dec 2017,10:34 PM IST

ADVERTISEMENT
SCROLL FOR NEXT