Presidential Election: Sonia’s Unifying Role is Unlikely to Work

Even if Sonia’s attempt to set up a ‘gathbandhan’ does succeed, who will be its leader?

The scene is very different for the Congress this time when it comes to the presidential elections. (Photo: Reuters)

As in 2004, Sonia Gandhi is again trying to stitch together an alliance against the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP).

The objective is to field an opposition candidate for the presidential poll where the BJP-led National Democratic Alliance (NDA) is short of a majority in the 1.1-million strong electoral college – although by no more than two percent of the votes.

However, if the opposition fields a widely acceptable candidate and is able to lure a few of the BJP's allies – like the generally disgruntled Shiv Sena – to its side, then the “secular” front will be able to score a morale-boosting victory.

Sonia Can’t Hope to Be a Unifier This Time

It may be recalled that the Shiv Sena had voted against the BJP in the last two presidential elections. (Photo: Reuters)

It may be recalled that the Shiv Sena had voted against the BJP in the last two presidential elections, when it supported the Congress's Maharashtrian nominee Pratibha Patil in 2007 against the saffron stalwart Bhairon Singh Shekhawat, and the Congress' Pranab Mukherjee in 2012 against the former Lok Sabha Speaker PA Sangma.

Notwithstanding the Congress president’s initiative in reaching out to virtually everyone in the non-BJP camp, it will be unrealistic, however, to expect the kind of success which she had as a unifier in 2004 because there are significant differences between then and now.

In 2004, she was able to bring over to her side several of the BJP's allies like Ram Vilas Paswan's Lok Janshakti Party and Farooq Abdullah's National Conference because Atal Bihari Vajpayee's 24-party alliance was unravelling in the aftermath of the 2002 Gujarat riots.

Indeed, Vajpayee later said that he would not have lost but for the riots.

A Weak Congress, Soaring BJP

The scene is different this time. For one, unlike Vajpayee at the end of his reign, Narendra Modi is currently much more securely placed. For another, the Congress is now weaker than ever before.

In 2004, it was poised to climb higher – which it did five years later when it won more than 200 Lok Sabha seats – while the BJP was described as a “kati patang” by a former minister in Vajpayee's cabinet, Arun Shourie.

Now, the jibe of being a floating kite applies to the Congress as its Lok Sabha tally has fallen to its lowest-ever point while the BJP is soaring high.

The crown prince remains something of a part-timer in politics. (Photo: Reuters)

Moreover, the fact that Sonia is having to play a proactive role despite her indifferent health shows that Rahul Gandhi, who has long been expected to replace her as the party president, has failed to fulfil the Congress's expectations of becoming an acclaimed leader with ideas and energy. Instead, the crown prince remains something of a part-timer in politics.

Sonia, too, has lost some of the lustre which she had a decade ago because her missteps during the Congress's stint in power – such as stalling the economic reforms in favour of populism – are widely believed to have led the party to its doom.

Disparate Groups

It is not only that former Finance Minister P Chidambaram subsequently admitted that the Manmohan Singh government made the mistake of taking the “foot off the accelerator of reforms”, the reason for this politically fatal error could be seen in the observation of Aruna Roy, a member of the Left-leaning National Advisory Council headed by Sonia, that the government was placing too much emphasis on growth instead of on welfare measures. It was easy for Modi, therefore, to take over the growth agenda.

it will be difficult for Sonia to promise a new dawn in the company of losers like Sharad Pawar of the Nationalist Congress Party, Mulayam Singh Yadav of the Samajwadi Party. (Photo: Reuters)

Given this background of failure, it will be difficult for Sonia to promise a new dawn in the company of struggling leaders like Sharad Pawar of the Nationalist Congress Party, Mulayam Singh Yadav of the Samajwadi Party and MK Stalin of the DMK.

Besides, it is difficult to see how disparate groups like Lalu Prasads Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD), Mamata Banerjee's Trinamool Congress, Mayawati's Bahujan Samaj Party, Omar Abdullah's National Conference and Sitaram Yechury's CPI-M will be able to act like a coherent political formation.

Needless to say, there is nothing to bind these parties in terms of ideology except their dislike of the BJP.

It will be instructive to recall how an attempt to constitute a Janata “parivar” comprising the Samajwadi Party, the Janata Dal-United, the Janata Dal-Secular and the Indian National Lok Dal fell apart even before it could be formed.

Even if, for argument’s sake, Sonia’s attempt to set up a gathbandhan does succeed, who will be its leader? (Photo: Reuters)

True, a mahagathbandhan or a grand alliance made up of the RJD, the Janata Dal-United and the Congress, among others, proved to be an electoral success in Bihar in 2015. But a similar attempt came a cropper in Uttar Pradesh this year, showing that such opportunistic combinations are not easy to put together.

Even if, for argument's sake, Sonia's attempt to set up a gathbandhan does succeed, who will be its leader? The Congress president herself can be ruled out because of her health and the “foreign origin” stigma while none of the others, whether Sharad Pawar or Mulayam Singh, is a person who can match Modi's popularity.

The innate distrust between these parties is also likely to come in the way of proposing an agreed name for the President's post.

It will not be too far off the mark to suggest, therefore, that the opposition parties are chasing a mirage.

(This article has been published in an arrangement with IANS.)

(Amulya Ganguli is a political analyst. He can be reached at [e-mail]. This is an opinion piece and the views expressed above are the author’s own. The Quint neither endorses nor is responsible for the same.)