Are Men in India Culturally Superior to Women: HC on Marital Rape

“There is nothing like Indian and western society. Are men and women different in other nations?” the HC asked.

(Photo: Reuters)

“Are men in India culturally superior that they cannot be thought of committing marital rape?”

This was a poser to the authorities by the Delhi High Court which said this was a "serious issue".

A bench of Acting Chief Justice Gita Mittal and Justice C Hari Shankar said:

There is nothing like Indian and western society. Are men and women different in other nations? Are men in India culturally superior? It (marital rape) is a serious issue and it has become part of the culture.

The observations by the bench came when it was told by some NGOs, representing men, that India had a different culture from other nations where there are laws against marital rape.

The bench was hearing two PILs dealing with an exception in Indian penal law that does not consider sexual intercourse with a minor wife, above 15 years of age, as rape.

The exception in section 375 of IPC, which deals with the offence of rape, was brought by way of the Criminal Law Amendment Act of 2013, which was enacted after the horrific gang rape case of 16 December 2012.

One of the petitioners, an NGO, has claimed that the exception was "unconstitutional and violative of the Right to Equality guaranteed to married women under Article 14 of the Constitution as it decriminalises rape when the perpetrator is the lawfully wedded husband of the victim."

The NGO, RIT Foundation, has claimed that marital rape has been criminalised in almost all major common law jurisdictions throughout the world, including in United States, United Kingdom, South Africa and Canada.

The Centre had defended its legislation saying child marriages were taking place in India and the decision to retain a girls minimum age as 15 years to marry was taken under the amended rape law to protect a couple against criminalisation of their sexual activity, adding that husbands have been protected from prosecution for any sexual act with their wives who are above 15 years of age, in view of the "social reality" of child marriages in India.