Uber vs Ola Battle for Indian Market Travels From Streets to Court

It’s an ongoing legal battle between the two cab-hailing apps — each accusing the other of behaving unethically.

War of the app based taxi service. Uber’s logo (left) and Olacabs’ logo (right). (Photo Courtesy: Facebook)

Aiming to wrest control of India’s booming taxi market, two cab-hailing smartphone apps — Uber and Ola — are promising hundreds of millions in new investment while also facing off with one another in court.

San Francisco-based Uber reportedly plans a $500 million infusion of new funds, apart from the $1 billion already committed over the past nine months, according to newspaper reports.

The company declined this week to comment on those reports. Meanwhile, Ola Cabs promises to add another 2,000 cars to the fleet of 26,000 it already commands in the national capital, chief spokesman Anand Subramanian said.

But it’s the ongoing legal wrangles between the two — with each accusing the other of behaving unethically — that have drawn focus to the struggle for India’s $9 billion taxi industry and future growth possibilities in a country with an urban population of 400 million people but few options in safe, convenient public transportation.

‘Fake Accounts’: Uber Files Suit Against Ola

This month, Uber filed a suit against Ola, accusing its Bangalore-based rival of hijacking its business by creating fake accounts to make bookings with Uber that it then cancelled. Ola denied the allegations, calling them ludicrous and suggesting they were a smoke screen to hide Uber’s own troubles. Ola previously challenged Uber in court over what it said were illegal business practices.

Analysts say the court battles show competition for market dominance is becoming fierce.

Also Read: Uber Accuses Ola Of Making Fake Accounts to Interfere in Business

It’s a tussle to capture the top spot among taxi-hailing apps and the title of No. 1.

<b>Jaspal Singh, Founder, Valoriser Consultants</b>

Smartphone taxi apps, introduced in India in 2010, have grown to account for 10 percent of the country’s overall taxi industry, which also includes regular cabs and three-wheeler “rickshaws.”

Ola has already bought out the upstart TaxiForSure, and both Uber and Ola offer rates below those of traditional taxis. Meanwhile, they are quickly adding new cities and customers, including car drivers increasingly fed up with traffic gridlock and difficulty finding parking on India’s overcrowded roads.

Publicity image of Ola cabs. (Photo Courtesy: Twitter/@OlaCabs)

Ola Dominates App Market

So far Ola has been dominating the smartphone app market, with a presence in more than 100 cities and roughly half of the business, analysts say. Uber, which entered the Indian market in 2013, operates in 29 Indian cities and is anxious to expand, while myriad small players are clawing their way in.

• Uber demands $7.4 million in damages from Ola.
  
• Uber alleges Ola and backing firms have created more than 90,000 fake accounts.
  
• In 2014, Lyft accused Uber of booking and cancelling thousands of rides.
  
• Delhi HC to hold hearing in September for Uber vs Ola case.
  
• In October 2015, Ola filed suit against Uber saying the latter did not obey SC rules.

Legal Action

In the latest legal action between the two, filed in the Delhi High Court, Uber demanded an injunction against Ola and $7.4 million in damages. It accused Ola — backed by Japan’s SoftBank Group Corp. and hedge fund Tiger Global Management — of creating more than 90,000 fake accounts to book around 400,000 rides and then cancel them in an effort to disrupt Uber’s business.

The allegations are similar to those faced by Uber itself in the United States in 2014, where San Francisco-based Lyft accused Uber of booking and canceling thousands of rides. Uber denied the accusations and no legal action was filed.

The Delhi High Court will hold its next hearing in September on Uber’s lawsuit, which Ola called “frivolous and false.”

Ola said in a statement it was “not beyond our imagination that this is an effort to divert attention from the current realities of the market where Uber has faced major setbacks.”

Specifically, those setbacks include a legal petition filed by Ola in October, accusing Uber of flouting a Supreme Court order demanding app-based taxis in New Delhi switch from running on diesel to using compressed natural gas.

The companies were given until this month to comply with the rules, intended to curb extreme air pollution in the capital. Ola’s parent company, ANI Technologies, has alleged Uber’s lawsuit is retaliation against Ola’s petition.

Uber app on mobile. (Photo: Reuters)

Uber had earlier troubles in India as well. It was accused of failing to properly screen its drivers in 2014 after one was accused of raping a 26-year-old passenger. Uber’s reputation temporarily took a hit, and the government briefly banned all smartphone app taxi services while new regulations were drafted.

Read: Uber Rape Survivor Withdraws Case in US “With Prejudice”

The current wrangling over ethics and legal threats is not limited to Uber and Ola.

Last week, rickshaw booking app Jugnoo, operating in the north Indian city of Chandigarh, accused Ola of using “unethical practices to sabotage its business” by making fake bookings and warned of legal action if it did not cease.

Jugnoo CEO Samar Singla said his company saw a sudden surge in bookings and cancelations, with about 20,000 cancelations made through 800 accounts over a 10-day period earlier this month.

We started mapping the areas where the bookings were being made from, and it invariably pointed to places close to Ola’s office.

<b>Samar Singla, CEO, Jugnoo</b>

Jugnoo, the rickshaw booking app. (Photo: Jugnoo’s Facebook page)

Singh, the transportation analyst, said Uber and Ola were honing their strategies and boosting services to secure market dominance as the country experiments with transportation limits aimed at curbing air pollution.

On 15 April, New Delhi will begin banning cars with odd- or even-numbered license plates from the roads on alternate days for two weeks. The capital’s first such effort in January helped lessen air pollution and traffic.

(Photo: Reuters)

Residents say they will be relying on cab companies to travel in the city during those weeks.

The last time I just ordered a cab from my phone. For me it doesn’t matter if it’s Ola or Uber. It’s so convenient, I could park my car in the garage permanently.

<b>Rashmi Singh, Advertising Executive</b>

Also Read: Odd-Even 2nd Phase: DCW Seeks Women’s Suggestions on Exemption